Introducing our Signature Cookie Gift Box – the ultimate cookie sampling experience that brings together all six of our beloved signature creations in one irresistible package. This collection delivers the perfect taste of what makes our Market special, featuring two of each cookie: Betty Ballou's, Chunky Mal's, Double Shakalate, Monsters, Oatmeal Raisin, and Pecan Sally's for a delightful variety that satisfies every craving and showcases the full range of our baking expertise. Each Cookie Gift Box contains twelve perfectly baked cookies and is finished with a handwritten gift message.
Made fresh daily in our kitchen, The Friendly Market cookies are produced using shared equipment that processes dairy, peanuts, soy, tree nuts, eggs and wheat. While we take precautions to minimize cross-contact, we cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment.
Please see FAQ page for detailed ingredients for each cookie.
Enjoy cookies within three days of receiving.
Or freeze for up to thirty days. Set on the counter until thawed & enjoy!
Do not refrigerate!
Betty Ballou Cookies – Our beloved family recipe that elevates the classic chocolate chip cookie with sweet coconut flakes and crunchy pecans. A treasured recipe passed down through generations, Betty guarded this secret for years before finally sharing it with her daughter – and now with all of you.
Chunky Mals – The perfect answer to the salty-sweet dilemma, featuring chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, potato chips, and sea salt in one addictive bite. Created in 2024 by our talented baker who understood that sometimes you don't have to choose between cravings – you can have both.
Double Shakalate – Our ultimate double chocolate indulgence with crisp edges and a soft, gooey center. Like a brownie in cookie form, with good vibes baked right in.
Monster Cookies – Our legendary gluten-free option loaded with peanut butter, oats, M&Ms, and chocolate chips. Shared with us in 2012 by a baking legend who taught us everything about achieving the highest quality and spreading pure joy.
Classic Oatmeal Raisin – Perfectly soft-baked and chewy, featuring oats, raisins, brown sugar, vanilla, and cinnamon in ideal harmony. Crafted in 2019 by our talented bakers who wanted to bring The Friendly Market touch to this timeless classic.
Pecan Sally – Our unique twist on the pecan sandie, loaded with white chocolate, coconut, pecans, and a secret crunch that'll make your tail wag. Named after our legendary Market Dog who greeted customers and brought smiles to everyone – customer-approved since summer 2018.
Picking a favorite cookie is just so hard. Lately, it’s the Double Shakalate, it’s a cookie but a brownie all at the same time. I might have even had one for breakfast this morning
I just love Betty Ballou cookies! They’re better than an Oreo, being dipped in milk!
I have a dementia patient, every visit I have with her I bring Chunky Mals. They are my secret weapon when she's not in the best of moods. I break out the cookies and I get smiles, hugs, and kisses! They are just perfect because they combine her 2 favorite things chocolate chip cookies and potato chips
The monster cookies are hands down the best plus the oats and peanut butter in them make me feel like they are healthier… but probably not when I eat the whole bag in a sitting 🤣 we love them so much we had them as a dessert option for our wedding and everyone else loved them too!
We love the Oatmeal Raisin cookies! They’re such a comfort cookie and you can never go wrong with a perfect Oatmeal Raisin cookie! Reminds me of grandma.
The Pecan Sally’s are always in my basket! Like the recipe came from a grandma's personal recipe box that she won’t share. I look forward to those each year.